Friday, 20 November 2026

Mind-reading and mental domination in Lord of the Rings (and Harry Potter)

It seems that the ability to communicate mind to mind (telepathically) in The Lord of the Rings (LotR) is something correlated with the racial stature of beings. For example, the premier mind-reader seems to be Sauron (a Maia) followed by Gandalf and Saruman. Next come the high elf Galadriel and Maia/ Elf/ Man descended Elrond; followed by Numenorean (part-elven) Men such as Aragorn, Denethor and Faramir. 


The ability to read minds goes with the ability to block mind-reading by others; to conceal one's thoughts from those of similar stature who are trying to perceive one's thoughts. 

Both mind-reading and mind-blocking also go along with the capacity to dominate, deceive, or daunt others. 

Beings of lower stature such as ordinary Men and Hobbit, cannot do these things, and are consequently more open to having their minds read; and to being dominated, daunted and deceived. 


Such is the generalization; but there are asymmetries; and it seems that a protective blocking against mind-reading has a price to pay. Sauron, Saruman and Denethor all - to varying degrees - have decided to  block their their minds as strongly as they can; and this seems to bring with it an intrinsic limitation on understanding the true motivations of others. 

All of these characters exhibit strongly what we might call "projection" - because none are able to understand the motivations of those who who do not share their own motivations. Neither Saruman nor Denethor can understand what is motivating Gandalf - even when face to face and eye to eye with him. 

Yet Gandalf can understand Saruman, Denethor - and indeed Sauron at a deep level. 


I think this has to do with the price to be paid for concealing intentions. In other words, one who blocks off his own mind, in the attempt to conceal his true motivations, in order to dominate, daunt and deceive others; by that same action inhibits his own sympathy, empathy... his capacity to attune to the real inner lives of others. 

It seems clear that Gandalf is - in general - a spontaneous and unguarded person. He does not try to dominate, daunt or deceive. And this is exactly what enables him so adept at understanding others - of all races and ranks. 


I think that here is represented is a genuine insight into human nature. We can all of us, in our own way and at our level; block our-selves from others - conceal our true motivations. 

This concealment by blocking is indeed the habit, necessity and expertise of many of those in positions of power in our society: political and corporate rulers, leaders of institutions and churches, intelligence operatives, advertisers, those in sales and marketing, media people... 

Indeed; mind-blocking is a standard job requirement among all medium to high level bureaucrats - and there are many such people - including many of the readership of this blog. 


My point here is that there is a price to pay for closing our minds - and it is a price paid in our capacity to understand and participate in the wider world. 

**


NOTE: Much the same phenomenon as described above can be seen in the Harry Potter series. 

In The Half Blood Prince, Dumbledore makes Harry take lessons with Snape to learn how to block his mind against the mind-reading intrusions (and manipulations) of Voldemort. 

Dumbledore and Snape are both highly skilled at legilimency, as is Voldemort; which is Rowling's term for the mind-reading/ blocking skill. Like Sauron and Saruman, Voldemort uses this skill to control and daunt his subordinates. 

But Harry cannot learn legilimency. At a deep level he does not want to learn how to block his mind; and I think this is implicitly because Harry does not want to pay the price of losing empathy and the capacity to understand, and identify with, others. 

Harry seems to guess that closing his mind will also alienate him from much of that which is real and good. 


This price has been paid both by Snape and Dumbledore to a significant degree. Snape can never understand Harry, although Snape can in a sense read Harry's mind; e.g. detect his lies and secrets. 

And while Dumbledore (much like Gandalf) does not use his legilimency in order to dominate and daunt; the concealment of his own motives, his secrecy and manipulations, all exert a terrible psychological cost on Dumbledore himself.

And this cost is shared by several others including Snape and also Harry, who are (mostly unwittingly) involved in Dumbledore's strategies. 


Harry Potter makes the choice to remain open, and take the consequences. 

But he therefore remains in sympathetically connected with with the people and world around him so as to work on their behalf.

And eventually Harry is able, by sympathetic participation, to understand Voldemort in order to defeat him*. 


*(Although even then, it is actually Voldemort who defeats himself, from his own self-blinding and cultivated incapacity to understand and empathize.) 


No comments: